THIS REVIEW CONTAINS SPOILERS I just copied this from my blogand, didn t realize until it was pointed out to me below that I didn t copy the whole thing sorry Please be warned this blog post contains SPOILERS for the following books One Day, Message in a Bottle, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, The Lord of the Rings, The Way We Were, A Walk to Remember, Atonement, Bridges of Madison County, The Time Travelers Wife, The English PatientThis is the first book that is so beautiful that I want to quote it and keep it with me, and, yet I hate itI mean seriously hate it I am sorry I read it, if I hadn t bought it on the Nook I d burn it I don t want to read any books by this author just incase he tricks me again I want toI am cryingshame on David Nicholls insert cuss words here And, no I WILL NOT be watching the movieseriously Yes, I hated the ending that much, not sinceAtonementhave I felt this emotionally cheated.Emma Morley dies and no, I, in no way, saw that coming Why didn t I see that coming because this bookOne Dayby David Nicholls a name that will be seared in my brain so I don t slip up and buy one of his books again was not advertised as a book in the same vain asMessage in a BottleSee, the thing is I hate when books have needless death and dying I hate books that intentionally kill off characters you love think the Weasley twin inHP7to make you cry, not to propel the plot along And, in this book, after reading about 360 pages of a wonderfully tormented friendship on the verge of something I was relating to the characters, to the places I mean Emma has a flat in Earl s Court, really, Earl s Court and I was relating to the hurt and desire of wanting your best friendhmmI was relating soooo much, that when Emma died I felt like a friend died and my breathing became erratic and my world darkened Frankly, if I d known this was going to happen, I wouldn t have read the book as I do not read such books And, that s just itI feel that Mr Nicholls had Emma die towards the end because yes, there s still like 30ish pages after her deathI don t know whyI suppose so you can short out your Nook crying while reading because that was the ending no one expected This is what I feel Nicholas Sparks, who is on my banned book list did withMessage in a Bottleand what I feel Ian McEwan did inAtonementwhat a shame the ending of that was and what I feelThe Time Travelers Wifewas, I mean that book doesn t even adhere to the science of time travel or the science it creates in the story if you canumer meet yourself, you can also save yourselfI mean he even knew what was over there in the forestgah I m not into gimmicks and I am not into tricks while reading I don t have to guess the ending and I don t have to see it coming, but I do have to feel, at the end, that the book and its characters led to the conclusion.I have, for many years, read books that use to death or separation to propel the plot I was a little sad that Boromir died inLord of the Rings , I was a little sad when Jaimie died inA Walk to Remember , and, I cried like someone died at the end ofBridges of Madison Countyyou know the part where all she has to do is get out of the truck and leave her whole life behind to be with the one she loves and she s there grabbing at the handle and you know she isn t going to do it, but you want her to, you really want her to , I don t mind that The English Patient dies, I don t mind that Hubbell and Katie never get together inThe Way We WereI understand weakness and I understand death when it is used in a proper way to drive home the major themes and symbols of a book or movie Nicholls used Emma s death to do neither.I read a review on GoodReads I read many reviews looking for closure and answers that talked about how David Nicholls wrote a book that didn t really address any audience and therefore made a certain type of audience incredibly upset This is true, maybe he didn t understand his audience I know I m all for learning about relationship mistakes in a work of fiction, I just don t need characters to die to do that I also know that there are people who love this book, just like there are people who can t get enough of Nicholas Sparks.I have had enough of both. I think reality is overrated This is a novel that takes you on a roller coaster of emotions It begins light, humorous, warm and aloof, just like most of us are once we graduate, all our efforts and studies paying off, looking into the future full of ideals, hopes and dreams Then we face adult life and responsibilities, disappointment, and all the disillusionment that eventually knocks our doors.At the heart of the story are Emma and Dexter, two young people who start out long time friends and one night lovers and go on becoming so much over the course of 20 years David Nicholls chooses to have each chapter dedicated to a single specific date, the 15th of July, a chapter for every year On this day, Emma and Dexter sometimes come together, sometimes they don t.Emma is an extremely interesting character Idealist, compassionate, cautious, caring She is no saint, of course, but she is the only presence in the book who knows what she wants and succeeds in overcoming the hurdles Dexter is not a likeable character and this is precisely as it should be He is not meant to be well liked, in my opinion His cockiness is actually a facade most of the times and Emma is the only person who helps him bring out his better self It is not an easy task and certainly not always successful What is very interesting and telling is the fact that these two often do whatever is possible to keep the other at a distance, but they are always brought together The secondary characters are really, really annoyingview spoiler The incident that makes the book a true success is one of the most heart wrenching moments, described in a single sentence at the very end of one of the last chapters It throws your heart to the beasts Call me melodramatic, but this is how it made me feel I felt a deep sadness, witnessing Death having the final word It was unfair, depressing, cruel Still, I don t really enjoy happy endings, they are far from realistic, and one must applaud David Nicholls boldness hide spoiler Frankly, after reading a spoiler about the ending, I simply have no will to continue on, there is just no pay off after enduring this depressing tale sprinkled with occasional one liners Granted, I am never opposed to taking a good dose of drama, but melodrama I detest.This story is about a man and a woman who one day come together as lovers, then break up, but stay connected Their relationship is followed through the next 20 years by presenting just one day July 15th out of their lives This is indeed a great premise and technique , but I wish they were used on different characters and situations Both Dexter and Emma are not likable enough for me to care to see how their relationship unfolds I dislike watching Dexter waste his life on partying and hooking up and Emma on pining over him for years There is nothing remotely romantic, deep, or compelling about it IMO.I agree with one of the reviewers here who said that the author didn t quite know his target audience One Day is neither a literary fiction which can spin the star crossed lovers theme in a meaningful way see Atonement , nor a light hearted chick lit some reviewers mistakenly compare this novel to the movie When Harry Met Sally It is somewhere in the middle, which is, IMO, a decently written relationship melodrama, perfect examples of which are The Time Traveler s Wife and tear jerkers by Nicholas Sparks, Jennifer Weiner,Jodi Picoult and the likes But alas, this is not my favored genre. Is love really all that difficult Yes, yes it is David Nicholls crafts a beautiful love story about two people who are so different that they really only have one thing in common they are both mad for each other The frustrating thing is though, that however much these two people love each other, they maintain a friends only status throughout most of the book What starts out as a possible love affair after just graduating college, Emma and Dexter s chemistry and attraction falls through the cracks as the years pass Distance, missed opportunities, and even a letter that never gets sent, are all obstacles that ultimately determine their romantic fate and and life that they may have led together when they were young Each character experiences struggles, dysfunctional relationships, setbacks, and successes and eventually it is clear that life is passing them by because their true soul mate is not truly in their life One Day offers laughs, tears, and insight and encourages to not limit yourself and if you truly want something, don t hold back If you re in love, go for it Missed opportunities are hard to overcome Don t let the years go by in vain Thanks David Nicholls for such a glorious, heartbreaking read. Popular Ebook, One Day By David Nicholls This Is Very Good And Becomes The Main Topic To Read, The Readers Are Very Takjup And Always Take Inspiration From The Contents Of The Book One Day, Essay By David Nicholls Is Now On Our Website And You Can Download It By Register What Are You Waiting For Please Read And Make A Refission For You Every moment with this book felt like a waste of my time I ve seen it all before the ugly duckling pining after the rich asshole who could be transformed into a better man if he only realized that the right woman was right there in front of him This plot is so well trod that I feel like there are hundreds of better examples of it that I could have been reading And here is the thing, I love these kinds of stories as the size of my romance shelf can attest But I hated these characters so much that I couldn t root for them And as to the ending, can I just say that I didn t like it the first time it happened in City of Angles, and I still didn t like it when Nicholls ripped it off. DELL ALTEZZA, MA SOPRATTUTTO DELLA BASSEZZA Non sono un fan di Hornby.Neppure di Coe, ma per lui ho pi interesse.Per , non abbastanza interesse da arrivare in fondo a questo libro nonostante la sua raccomandazione.Mi avevano detto che le prime 70 100 pagine non erano all altezza delle seguenti ma nessuno mi aveva avvertito della bassezza sono arrivato a 124, un quarto del libro, e direi che basta, non necessario bere tutta la botte per sapere se il vino buono.So gi dove vuole andare a parare Nicholls vuole farmi piangere a tutti i costi la sua vendetta per Love Story che mi lasci impassibile.Nicholls uno sceneggiatore, di TV e cinema la sua professione principale determina la sua scrittura, secondo me, in modo vistoso e insopportabile tutto un dare indicazioni indicazioni per il futuro regista ch tanto tutti i suoi libri finiscono sullo schermo, evidente l intento qui per esempio, c Anne Smorfietta Hathaway all opera nella parte di Emma , indicazioni per gli attori, per il casting E anche indicazioni per il lettore, che invece, nel mio caso, vorrebbe essere libero di interpretare a sua scelta ma non pu , perch tutto smaccato e sottolineato Il mestiere col quale Nicholls si guadagna da vivere viene fuori anche nella mediocrit della scrittura.Vogliamo poi parlare della sciattezza della traduzione e dell edizione Peccato, perch uno dei due traduttori Marco Rossari, di cui ho letto un paio di libri interessanti e divertenti Passerotta e passerotto in One Day Un giorno di Lone Scherfig, 2011.Gi a p.2 leggo che Emma prov per lui un brivido rassicurante di repulsione Ho provato a lungo a immaginare come Anne Hathaway ci mostrer un brivido rassicurante di repulsione nei confronti di Dexter Jim Sturgess e probabilmente l unica cosa di questo romanzo che mi rester da scoprire perch , il film io certo non lo vedr Ecco un altra chicca per la Hathaway a un certo punto dovr scivolare gi dallo sgabello come se stesse per tuffarsi nelle acque del Polo Nord Cara Anne, ti aspetta una dura prova Ma so che con le solite smorfiette riuscirai a portare il compito a casa, come ha fatto Meg Ryan per anni Poi ci sono le lettere che i due si scambiano, dove Nicholls d il meglio di s nel senso, ovviamente, del peggio di s parole tutte in maiuscolo, acronimi che dovrebbero far sorridere, sottolineature, giovanilismi vari, un mix tremendo che spingerebbe a saltare queste zone della narrazione, se non fosse che il racconto procede proprio attraverso queste lettere Miciotto e miciotta.Evito l elenco di tutte le mie sottolineature alla scelta di metafore o alle descrizioni o alle battute di dialogo che Nicholls adotta e che secondo me non sono degne di Harmony che non ho mai letto, e forse per questo, rispetto di pi Aggiungo che i personaggi sono insopportabili alla faccia dell originalit , proprio come in Love Story , lui ricco e lei no Dexter un avventuriero, un pioniere perch esce con un paio di jeans bermuda senza mutande, impavido e spudorato Non ha mai visto un film di Fellini anche se vive e insegna a Roma Emma gli dicediventare una intellettuale coscienziosa. Dexter non era sicuro di capire quel termine, ma all interno della parola coscienziosa aveva individuato cosce e questo pavlovianamente bast a provocargli una mezza erezione O anche Dexter non amava farsi passare per un vanesio, ma a volte avrebbe voluto che ci fosse qualcuno nei paraggi a importunarlo con la macchina fotografica Mi pare non ci sia bisogno di commenti Piccioncina e piccioncino.Ma se non bastasse, pi avanti si legge perfino che nei rari momenti d insicurezza, Dexter si era preoccupato che la sua scarsa intelligenza potesse penalizzarlo nella vita, ma il suo era un lavoro dove contavano soprattutto la fiducia in se stessi, l energia, magari anche un po di arroganza, tutte qualit che erano alla sua portata S , bisognava essere intelligenti, ma non come Emma Bastava essere maneggioni, furbi, arrivisti Lei, Emma, anche peggio di lui non solo perch innamorata di un tomo simile, ma anche perch gi vecchia a 20 anni, bacchettona, rigida, si lamenta sempre, probabilmente gi malata di qualcosa, e non riesce neppure a godersi il fatto di essere una bellissima ragazza Tenerella e tenerello.E poi, ci sarebbe da aggiungere che la deliziosa trovata di dividere il romanzo per capitoli che si svolgono tutti nello stesso giorno, il 15 luglio, uno a distanza di un anno dall altro, per me risulta una scelta perdente e frustrante, un po come beh, lasciamo perdere Tra l altro, ho gi visto un paio di film con questa struttura e non mi sono piaciuti per niente Mi accorgo che mischio libri e film come se fossero della stessa natura Il fatto che questo romanzo sostanzialmente una sceneggiatura rilegata PSQuesto libro nella mia lista scambiabili spero che trovi subito qualcuno interessato, non vedo l ora di liberarmene E il 29 settembre ci sono riuscito, me ne sono liberato Evviva Lupacchiotta e lupacchiotto. Let s talk about death Not death which is inevitably part of life, but death in fiction, where it is not inevitable at all Death in fiction is a deliberate, well thought out decision the writer is God, and he or she is choosing, for whatever reason, to Strike This Character Down.There are good fictional deaths, and ones which feel cheap This book lost me for good because it contains a death that felt exactly like the hand of God reaching down Oh, thought the writer god, I don t really know how to end this but I know that an element of tragedy will make this novel seem super deep Die, character, dieThis did not seem like a senseless death of that type that in real life is imbued with honest tragedy It felt like an author scrambling for a final act, and not being brave enough to let his characters simply face the rest of their lives together To die might be a very great adventure, as Peter Pan says, but Peter Pan is an eternal child Isn t this book supposed to be about growing up Isn t the greatest adventure simply living But let s stay with youthful mistakes for a minute You see, the thing is I wrote this novel I don t say this out of jealousy It should be me with this bestseller, me with a movie deal and Nick Hornby praising me on his blog No Not that I wouldn t like all of those things one day I totally would but the novel I wrote, which shares a freakish number of similar elements with this one, sucked I mean, it really stank This novel, it must also be noted, is much, much better than mine was the prose is an improvement over mine at the time I was 20 or 21 , and I m pretty damn sure that this book is realistic, and consistently funny and emotionally engaging, than my juvenile effort However, there are definite and bizarre similarities both books are about a friendship between a man and a woman over a long stretch of time, beginning in the 80s both are about struggling to strike a balance between financial solvency and artistic integrity both star a character named Em really, it s eerie and both feature a tragic bicycle accident It s the tragic bicycle accident that really gets me I saw the one in One Day coming from miles away, and approached it with increasing incredulity Because I had done the tragic bicycle accident, in the shitty novel I wrote when I was 20, and it was dumb then and it is dumb now It s the hand of the author coming down and going, Look Look I AM GOING TO MAKE YOU CRY GODDAMMIT Since none of you has read my novel thank god , this comparison lacks something So allow me to make another one This involves yet another embarrassing confession I really, really like the movie City of Angels Yes, the one with Nicolas Cage and Meg Ryan completely honestly, I do I also love the movie it was based on, Wings of Desire I remember at some point discussing our mutual appreciation for these two films with my mother Which did we prefer I know I hesitated, because as much as I love Wings of Desire, I also think it drags at certain points that long, lengthy speech in the bar at the end What s that about City of Angels, thoughHere my mom stepped in, definitive She liked Wings of Desire better, because of the crucial difference in the movies endings See, in Wings of Desire, the angel falls, finds the woman he loves, there is a pretentious speech in a bar, and then they justgo on living That s the ending they must face the consequences of living In City of Angels, on the other hand, the angel falls, finds the woman he loves, and then the very next morningshe dies IN A FREAKIN TRAGIC BICYCLE ACCIDENT Seriously, what gives Are we all just a bunch of scarred Nico fans inside Is this a public safety announcement of some kind Kids Wear a helmet or your death may facilitate the important, if sadly belated, epiphanies of your loved ones No, but quite honestly, I think my mom was right that the bolder, braver ending can sometimes be the one that s not about GRAND TRAGEDY, but that s simply about the everyday struggle and joy of living How is that not an equally valid story to tell The fact that David Nicholls seemed to do everything in his power to ultimately avoid telling it really frustrated me This novel definitely has its charm it s snarky and English its central device is clever its depiction of feeling lost and aimless in your twenties seemed spot on But in part because of its clever format too many of this story s important moments happened off stage, and the one is led to believe central event of its two protagonists finally, finally falling in love is downplayed horribly so that dun dun dun the tragic bicycle accident can occur several chapters later I felt cheated and manipulated, frankly, having slogged through 300 pages of the male lead behaving like an utter ass while not a lot of other stuff happened all that, for this And sure, one could argue that that sense of disappointment is realistic to life But I would counter that it doesn t make for very good fiction.Neither does the fact that this book has endings padding out its already hefty page count than The Return of the King You d already lost me with the tragic bicycle accident, dude, can we just wrap this up already Your internet profile was enthralling, but on a one to one level it just isn t working Let s split the check and go our separate ways Maybe in ten years time I ll look back on this and laugh in twenty I ll have forgotten your name. Why do these two like each other, exactly Opening LineI suppose the important thing is to make some sort of difference So I m going to try to write a somewhat sensible review here that doesn t come across as all gushy fan girl I will say hopefully only once that I adored this book but you should know that I m a bit of a sucker for a tragedy too ONE DAY was brilliant in every way making me laugh and cry while filling me with nostalgia and longing And because I m the same age as Dexter and Emma the time frame here was also totally relatable see nostalgia with little details I had forgotten about from the past two decades.Equal parts heartbreaking and hilarious yet also suspenseful as each chapter takes place a year to the day after the last one so you have to figure out what s happened in that time between And of course you want the H h to get together so you re waiting with bated breathe for them to finally see each other too In the end this also made me want to seize the day like it s my last, phone up all my long lost friends and lovers and look at old photographs Hmmm and I haven t even gotten into the genius of the writing yet how do you put that into words I knew that writing a review here was going to be difficult when you love a book this much there doesn t seem to be enough correct words to do it justice and I promised myself to just keep this short and to the point so here goes This is one of the most hilarious, perceptive, witty, moving and heartbreaking books I have ever read Told in 5 parts in alternating POV s and over a span of twenty years Dexter Mayhew and Emma Morley meet in 1988 Em has just graduated from university and hooked up with that boy she s seen around for ages He is Dexter, beautiful, pretentious and in his mind destined for greatness As the sun rises they drink wine and talk about their futures They have their whole lives stretching out ahead of them in an endless number of days and isn t it going to be wonderful they can achieve anything they want to Starting as lovers Dexter and Emma continue as friends and the book joins them on July 15th of each year St Swithin s day through their 20 s and 30 s and into their 40 s As anyone in their 40 s knows, life happens and it doesn t always go as planned, missed opportunities and the likeWhen I was younger everything seemed possible Now nothing doesThrough phone calls and letters, in different countries and towns, through assorted relationships, jobs and life s little surprises and ruts we join Em and Dex each year in a unique snapshot of their life They don t always get along but they do think about each other everyday in some way and in case you haven t figured it out this is ultimately a love story I can t say much about this without giving it all away But when I read the last word I wanted to start it again and nothing I ve tried to read since compares CheersLive each day as if it s your last, that was the conventional advice, but really, who had the energy for that
Starter for Ten was featured on the first Richard and Judy Book Club.
- 435 pages
- One Day
- David Nicholls
- 04 February 2019 David Nicholls